Gas vs Electric Fireplace: Which Is Better?

Do you want a fireplace in your home this winter? Both fireplaces have their own pros and cons. Some may prefer gas fireplaces because of their warm glow and impressive flames, but what if you have an old home with limited fuel pipes? Fortunately, the modern fireplace has evolved. Now it can be the best of both worlds by getting a gas and/or electric fireplace to match your style and function. Read on to learn which is better, gas vs electric fireplace.


When deciding on a new fireplace, it is important to consider which type is best for your home: gas or electric. Gas fireplaces are considered the traditional option and use natural gas, propane, or gel fuel to start a fire.

They generally require professional installation as there will be a gas line to be run to the unit, and the connection must be done properly and in compliance with local codes. Electric fireplaces require minimal installation, offer far more fireplace design options, and require no additional fuels.

Operating Costs

When it comes to comparing gas fireplaces vs electric fireplaces in terms of operating costs, it is certainly true that gas fireplaces can be much more expensive to run and maintain over time. This is due mainly to the fact that gas fireplaces require natural gas or propane, which can be quite costly.

Gas fireplaces also need to be vented, which introduces additional labor and material costs. Although electric fireplaces don’t require any fuel or venting, the cost of electricity can be considerable over the life of the appliance.

Furthermore, electric fireplaces are not as powerful as gas fireplaces and may require supplemental heating solutions to warm larger rooms.


Both gas and electric fireplaces require maintenance to ensure it operates safely and optimally. Gas fireplaces need to be checked yearly and serviced every two to three years. During service, the technician will check the venting, glass, maintenance, air supply, gas supply, and other safety components to make sure they are operating correctly.

It may also need to be cleaned and inspected for any signs of carbon monoxide leakage, rust, corrosion, or other signs of damage. Electric fireplaces require much less maintenance. However, they require regular dusting and vacuuming, and the filter should also be changed or replaced every six months.


Fireplaces around the world have long since been a traditional hearth and home feature. When it comes to modern fireplaces, gas and electric varieties are the two most popular. When it comes to safety, each type of fireplace has its own advantages.

Gas fireplaces are not only efficient, but they’re also ventless and sealed systems. This means that they won’t release any toxins or particulates into the home, making them very safe. Electric fireplaces are also an efficient, safe option. They don’t require fuel, and they don’t need to be vented.

They also won’t release any toxins, which makes them a great choice for those who have asthma or other respiratory issues. Ultimately, both gas and electric fireplaces can provide a safe and efficient heating source, so it really comes down to personal preference.

Environmental Impact

When it comes to the environmental impact of gas vs electric fireplaces, there are significant differences. Gas fireplaces create more pollutants and emissions into the environment due to the combustion that comes from burning natural gas.

Electric fireplaces are much cleaner, producing no emissions of any kind since the heat is produced without combustion. Electric fireplaces can be powered by renewable energy sources such as solar, while gas fireplaces use fossil fuels, resulting in more emissions.

Design Flexibility

When it comes to design flexibility, gas, and electric fireplaces both have their own advantages. Gas fireplaces are typically more aesthetically pleasing in a home as they provide a realistic, cozy feel and a variety of design options to match the architecture of the home.

They are easier to install as well, simply requiring a gas line to be run from the home’s gas meter and a chimney connection. Electric fireplaces, on the other hand, are extremely affordable and require no installation costs. They are also convenient because, with a flick of a switch on the wall and no ventilation needed, they can be turned off and on instantly.

Heat Effectiveness

When it comes to heat effectiveness, gas and electric fireplaces, both provide heat. However, the overall effectiveness can vary greatly. A gas fireplace uses natural gas, which is more efficient and provides a more consistent heat distribution throughout the space.

An electric fireplace, on the other hand, is more cost-effective in terms of installation and can be controlled more easily. Though an electric fireplace does not necessarily provide as much heat as a gas fireplace due to its lower BTU output, it is still able to heat a space effectively.

Check out these modern lobby fireplace designs to get this started!

Explore the Difference of Gas vs Electric Fireplace

A gas fireplace is usually better for a home, as it is easy to use, doesn’t require electricity, and is usually more cost-effective. An electric fireplace is good to use if you don’t have access to gas, but they are not as convenient, efficient, or cost-effective.

If you’re deciding between gas vs electric fireplace, then gas is the obvious choice. Contact a local fireplace retailer today to find the perfect size and style for your home.

If you want to explore the best topics, we’ve got you covered. Check out some of our other blogs today!

Yvan Lebrun
Yvan Lebrun

Yvan Lebrun is a trusted expert in the field of product & service reviews. With over a decade of experience analyzing and comparing services online, he shares his valuable experience with readers at GoodSitesLike so consumers can make educated decisions before making a purchase.